Last week, two facts were sure:
1. It was time for another cookie critique.
2. I was treating a dorm-mate to Starbucks at the end of the week.
In my mind, everything was aligning perfectly.
So I made a special trip to Duncan Donuts a few days later only to learn that my local Duncan Donuts doesn’t sell oatmeal cookies! 😢
Appearance: 2.5 – It wasn’t a perfect circle, and the raisins were not evenly distributed.
Texture: 3 – I know that my scoring only goes up to 2 points for texture, but this cookie was honestly perfect. It was so soft that it earned bonus points!
Taste: 2.5 – it tasted like coffee. No joke. other than that, it was delicious, wholesome and consistent.
Final score: 8 out of 10